The Mahabharata Is a Library, Not a Book

The Mahabharata runs to roughly 100,000 shlokas, verse couplets, making it around ten times the combined length of the Iliad and the Odyssey and among the longest epic poems produced by any civilisation. Length alone would be a curiosity; what makes the scale meaningful is what the length contains. The Mahabharata is not simply a long telling of one war. It is a central narrative, the succession conflict between the Pandavas and Kauravas culminating in the battle of Kurukshetra, wrapped around an enormous quantity of embedded material: philosophical dialogues, legal and political treatises, other complete myths and love stories told by characters to one another, and extended ethical debate that often has little direct bearing on the plot’s forward motion.

The Bhagavad Gita, arguably the single most influential text in the entire tradition, is one embedded section among many, a philosophical dialogue delivered on the battlefield at the story’s most dramatically tense possible moment, functioning almost as a work within the work. The Shanti Parva, one of the epic’s eighteen books, is largely devoted to Bhishma’s extended deathbed instruction on statecraft, ethics, and philosophy, running for thousands of verses with only loose narrative connection to the surrounding action.

This structure is a large part of why the text famously claims, in one of its own verses, that whatever is found here may be found elsewhere, but whatever is not found here exists nowhere at all. The claim reads less like arrogance and more like an accurate description of the text’s actual scope once its composite, accumulated nature is taken seriously: over centuries, the Mahabharata absorbed material from multiple sources and traditions into its frame narrative, functioning, in practice, as something closer to an anthology of the tradition’s ethical and philosophical concerns than to a single, tightly plotted story.

The tradition’s other great epic takes the opposite approach, a considerably tighter and more unified narrative, and yet it too resists being pinned to a single authoritative version, for reasons this series turns to next.


Continue reading in Hindu Mythology & Itihasa

Browse all 13 posts in Hindu Mythology & Itihasa